For the latest industry news, articles and advice on property management check out our new Resource Hub.

Effective tenant screening and selection: A guide for UK landlords

Jul 14, 2023 | Landlords, Tenants

As a landlord in the UK, finding reliable and responsible tenants is vital for a successful rental property. Tenant screening and selection are essential processes that can help you identify trustworthy individuals who will uphold their rental obligations. This article provides UK landlords with valuable insights and practical tips for effectively screening and selecting tenants for their rental properties.

It is worth noting that as of June 1, 2019, the Tenant Fees Act 2019 came into effect in England, which restricts the fees that landlords and letting agents can charge to tenants. This act prohibits landlords from charging fees for most aspects of the tenancy application process, including credit checks, reference checks, and inventory checks, among others.

Establish tenant criteria:
Define specific tenant criteria that align with your property and rental requirements. Consider factors such as desired income level, employment stability, rental history, creditworthiness, and any specific preferences or restrictions you may have. Having clear criteria in place helps streamline the selection process.

Thorough application process:
Request prospective tenants to complete a comprehensive application form that captures essential information. Include sections for personal details, employment history, income verification, references, and previous rental history. Ensure the application includes consent for background and credit checks, in compliance with data protection regulations.

Background and credit checks:
Conducting thorough background and credit checks provides valuable insights into a tenant’s financial history, previous rental behaviour, and potential risks. Partner with a reputable credit agency or tenant screening service to obtain information on credit scores, debt obligations, criminal records, and previous eviction history. Make sure to obtain the applicant’s consent before conducting these checks.

Verification of income:
To ensure the tenant can afford the rent, verify their income by requesting recent pay stubs, employment contracts, or bank statements. Aim for a tenant’s income to be at least three times the monthly rental amount. This verification step helps mitigate the risk of non-payment or late payments.

Reference checks:
Contact previous landlords and references provided by the applicant to gain insight into their rental history, reliability, and conduct as tenants. Ask specific questions about rent payment punctuality, property maintenance, and overall tenancy conduct. These references can provide valuable information about the applicant’s suitability for your rental property.

Meet the prospective tenant:
Arrange a face-to-face meeting with the applicant. Use this opportunity to get to know them better, assess their communication skills, and gauge their demeanour. Ask relevant questions about their expectations, lifestyle, and reasons for seeking a new rental property. This interaction can help you determine if the tenant’s needs align with your property and rental terms.

Trust your gut feeling:
While objective criteria and screening methods are important, trusting your intuition is also valuable. Pay attention to your instincts about a prospective tenant’s sincerity, reliability, and compatibility with your rental property. A good personal connection can often lead to a successful landlord-tenant relationship.

Comply with legal obligations:
Ensure that your tenant selection process aligns with UK laws and regulations, including anti-discrimination laws. Treat all applicants fairly and equally, avoiding any bias or prejudice based on protected characteristics. Focus solely on objective criteria and make decisions based on merit and suitability.

Communicate clearly:
Once you have selected a tenant, communicate the terms of the tenancy agreement clearly and comprehensively. Outline rent payment schedules, deposit requirements, maintenance responsibilities, and any specific rules or restrictions. Maintaining open and transparent communication sets the tone for a positive and cooperative tenancy.

Screening and selecting tenants for your rental properties is a critical task that requires a thorough and systematic approach. By establishing clear tenant criteria, conducting background checks, verifying income, checking references, and trusting your instincts, you can make informed decisions and secure reliable tenants. Strive to create a mutually beneficial relationship with your tenants, fostering a positive and successful rental experience for both parties.


Thinking of using a property management company to handle your properties? Or just starting out as a landlord? Contact us today to see how we can help.
Gaskells: 01457 876 677 or fill in our contact form and one of our team will call you back.